Lessons from the Boardwalk: Dave Allman on Bubbles, Gurus and Fifty Years of Markets
Some
of the best market education doesn't come from a textbook. It comes
from someone who has been there, made the mistakes, and is honest enough
to tell you about them. That's exactly what we got at this month's STA
meeting, when board member Jeff Boccaccio sat down for a fireside chat
with Dave Allman of Elliott Wave International, Bob Prechter's colleague for more than four decades.
It was one of the most entertaining evenings we've had, and also one of the most useful. Here are the lessons I took away.
A bubble on the boardwalk
Dave's
market education began on the boardwalk in Atlantic City, where he
started working at the age of 11. In November 1976, fifty years ago this
month, New Jersey voters approved casino gambling for the city. Two
years earlier the same idea had been rejected and the town was
depressed. Then everything changed.
When
Resorts International opened the first casino in May 1978, casino
stocks went, in Dave's word, "bananas." Resorts itself had once been the
Mary Carter Paint Company, and Dave recalls it going from around $2 to
over $200 within months. A concrete company that was merely rumoured
to have a building contract saw its shares take off. As Dave put it, it
was the 1970s equivalent of adding ".com" to your name in 1999, or
saying you're "getting into AI" today.
At
22, knowing nothing about stocks, Dave opened a margin account with
$2,000, bought Caesars World and watched it grow to around $40,000 by
that summer. Then in the autumn he learned "something very important,
which is that stocks can go down too." Thanks to the margin, the money
went, and more besides.
The lesson: every
boom has its own story, but the crowd behaviour is the same. Casino
stocks, dot-coms, crypto, AI. The names change; the psychology doesn't.
Beware the early win
Undeterred,
Dave moved on to options and got what he calls "stupid lucky" with some
far out-of-the-money calls. He says that win instilled a bad habit that
took years to break: buying cheap, out-of-the-money options in the hope
of a repeat. Most of them, of course, expired worthless.
Jeff
made a point I strongly agree with. Your first experience in the market
shapes your personality as a trader. Early success can be far more
dangerous than an early loss, because it teaches you the wrong lesson.
If you're new to markets and your first trades go well, be suspicious of
that success.
Granville, gurus and the road to Elliott
It
was Joe Granville who first drew Dave to technical analysis. Granville
was a showman. Dave saw him carried on stage like a pharaoh, and after
one bad call, carried in a coffin before "rising from the dead." When an
audience member asked about a utility stock he hadn't mentioned after
he'd turned bearish on utilities, Granville replied: "Lady, the market
doesn't know where you live."
After
three years as a broker (Dave admits he was "no good at sales"), he
read a photocopy of Bob Prechter's newsletter, contacted the MTA looking
for a job as a technical analyst, and was put in touch with Bob. Bob
wasn't hiring an analyst, but he needed an office manager. That was 43
years ago. Dave compared it to being interested in physics and going to
work for Einstein, and says Bob is still looking at five-minute charts
with the same passion he had on day one.
Have we lost something by not drawing charts by hand?
This
was the part of the evening that resonated most with me. The analysts
Dave interviewed for his book plotted their charts by hand. Justin
Mamis, he recalls, kept somewhere between 200 and 300 individual stock
charts. Dave himself kept an hourly Dow chart on graph paper, and joked
that if you had to tape another sheet to the top, the market was
probably peaking.
Today
we can scroll through thousands of charts and spray Fibonacci levels
over all of them at the press of a button. Dave half-jokingly "blames"
Bob for that. Charts default to candlesticks, yet he suspects most
people looking at them couldn't tell you what a hanging man or a hammer
is actually saying.
His
verdict? "I think we've lost something." Drawing each bar yourself
gives you a feel for the market's rhythm, its cycles and its psychology
that a screen full of indicators doesn't. Jeff added a timely point: AI
tends to give you the average answer from everything it has seen, and average isn't necessarily what you want to be trading on.
Try this:
pick one market you follow and plot it by hand for a month, even just a
weekly bar chart. You'll notice things you never see on screen.
Keep it simple
Asked
what tools he relies on beyond Elliott Wave, Dave's answer was
refreshingly simple: a plain black high-low-close bar chart on a white
background, and trend lines. In particular he loves a good "backside"
trend line, where price breaks the line and then comes back to "kiss" it
from the other side. He's also fond of ending diagonals and cycles.
On divergences he quoted Peter DeSario, "divergences are like laxatives. Is one enough? Are two too many?"
Nothing works all the time
The
most important message of the night was about humility. Dave has spent a
lifetime around traders and system builders hunting for the Holy Grail.
"There isn't one," he says. "Nothing works all the time. Some things
never work." He gave a perfect example: back in the early 1980s he
back-tested Gerald Appel's MACD on hourly NYSE data on a Radio Shack
TRS-80 with 16K of memory. The results were superb, because the test
period was a strong trend with no real pullbacks. Put real money behind
it in a different market and it falls apart.
His advice: you only need one thing that works for you.
If you find it, don't let anyone talk you out of it. Jeff added the
important caveat that you also need to recognise the market environment
your method works in.
Dave
was also candid about risk. Looking back, he says he has been caught
out by every technical tool there is, including a textbook head and
shoulders bottom complete with the right volume pattern. What protects
you isn't the tool. It's money management, position sizing, and doing
what you're comfortable with so you can sleep at night.
When everything lines up and still goes wrong
He
finished with a story every analyst should hear. In 1982, as a broker,
his biggest position was Flight Transportation. Fundamental analysts
loved it, earnings were soaring, and the technicians agreed; Stan
Weinstein rated it a strong Stage 2 stock. Then one day Dave watched the
quote tick down on his Quotron, and the screen went blank. Trading had
been halted. Regulators, it turned out, had been investigating the
company for months. When the stock reopened, Dave recalls it trading at
around $2.
Fundamentals and technicals were perfectly aligned. As Jeff summed it up: "Everything looks fine, till it didn't."
Markets are about psychology
Asked
whether today's AI-driven market looks like 1999–2000, Dave was careful
not to forecast. But he made a powerful point about valuation. Measures
such as price-to-sales peaked at one level in the 1960s, a much higher
level in 2000, and higher still today. Anyone who shorted at the old
"extreme" got run over. As Paul Montgomery used to say, values change
over time.
What
doesn't change is that markets are driven by psychology, not rational
calculation. Dave was pleased that behavioural finance has helped people
talk more about crowd behaviour, though he noted that most market
education is still heavily fundamental. And as he reminded us, the
market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent.
Wall Street Uncut
Much of the conversation drew on Dave's book, Wall Street Uncut,
published in March. It collects interviews he recorded in 1999 and 2000
with figures including Joe Granville, Stan Weinstein, Ned Davis, Ralph
Acampora, Justin Mamis, Victor Sperandeo and Arch Crawford. Dave
deliberately didn't ask for their market calls. He wanted the war
stories: how they got into the business and what they learned along the
way. As he says, every one of them has at least one insight worth taking
away, and you only need one.